Guardians of the Galaxy - Private Commission - SOLD OUT

[Luminous]

Originally Posted by thatkidwhodraws

I think the green planet was a good suggestion, makes the sky look more alien. Remember the Avengers is going to have a plain blue sky so I think the green planet will set it apart.

I could go either way

Here is the thing, since the final version was posted on Monday, I haven't seen anyone suggest a green planet. Aside from a question about the walkman next to the Marvel logo, I don't see any suggestions since then. When was a green planet suggested? I hope it wasn't via PM. EDIT: I see how this looks like an accusation. It is not. Just trying to clarify where the decision to change something came in.

I understand it's an attempt to balance out the green. I am just not convinced it's the solution. At least not in it's current form.

[Luminous]

Had to update my previous post. When I reread it I can see how someone could misinterpret my tone. I am simply looking for clarification.

[Hellboy]

Actually the more I look at it the more the green just looks like a green sticker in the corner. I suggest putting some rings around it like Saturn to make it look more like a planet or just revert to the white.

[FROBAY]

I can't live with the green. It's gotto be white. Looks like a 99 cent sticker.

[Bullseye]

No offence but some of the reactions are ridiculous. A white sticker is okay but not Green.

[Hellboy]

How is that ridiculous? The white with the light blue ring around it actually looks like a planet. The green is a good idea but I just don't think it works as is or looks like a planet. My 2 cents.

[FROBAY]

Originally Posted by Hellboy

How is that ridiculous? The white with the light blue ring around it actually looks like a planet. The green is a good idea but I just don't think it works as is or looks like a planet. My 2 cents.

Gotta agree!!

[Luminous]

The white wasn't distracting from the colors on the characters. Simple as that.

What about adding a layer of transparent inks over the green planet to help reduce the intensity of the green? Or some other shading technique like that.

[Bullseye]

Why not put a ring around the green planet? There was no blue ring shown around the white planet. Not that I have seen. Planets only look white when they are tiny not that scale in the sky.

[Bullseye]

If you put a bit of shading in the planet so that they look more like a crescent shape.