Quote:
Originally Posted by JM28Cardiff
Nobodies opinion is objective, an opinion is always subjective.
|
Very true. I was only referring to his film score. I realize those reflect an opinion as well, but when I see a movie score I see film a critique. Movie critics should criticize a film at an objective level. If there are personal opinions they should be noted as well, but those opinions do not change whether or not a film works on a particular level. Suggesting Prometheus is a film worthy of a 2/10 score implies the movie hardly works on any level at all.
If I hadn't seen the movie myself and I saw a score like that I would think some of the following occured:
-Poorly directed
-Poorly acted
-Poor editing
-Poor musical score
-Poor special effects
-Poor pacing
-Poorly scripted
-Poor cinematography
-Poor makeup
-Poor costume design
-Poor set design
-Poor art design
If it's in the movie, name it, and it's done poorly. Is that right? Perhaps if it was rated 2/10 and the poster stated that nothing, absolutely NOTHING worked for them.... then who could argue? Nothing worked for them. But no. Just a 2/10 and "this movie sucked". Sorry, that is amusing to me.
Again, this is just my own opinion.