Quote:
Originally Posted by Gothamite
New 52 4evah!
|
^ wasn't familiar with any of those. The only one I could recall off the top of my head was this one
That one is similar to the last two figures in your pic in that the lasso is not so much a lasso for the pose as it is simply a generic prop. Swap out the lasso for a sword, shield or staff with those figures and nothing needs to be demonstrably changed with regards to the figures attitude.
With the Hughes one the lasso is being used as a design element, but even then it's just a facile flourish.
The only one where the lasso is inherent to what the figure is shown doing is the first one and the SS PF.
Comparing how well each of those two statues executes their action, it becomes a matter of taste which one you prefer, I suppose.
For me, there is such a profound difference in skill and knowledge displayed between the two as there would be comparing a drawing by Michelangelo vs a cartoon by Bob Kane (and not a quality Kane ghost, but Kane himself).
Eh, maybe that's not fair. Kane was actually a miserable draftsman and that statue really isn't that bad. Just nowhere near the level of the Harbottle one (IMO of course).