Greatest Quarterback Game!

[statman]

1. Brett Favre 4
2. Dan Marino 7
3. John Elway 5
4. Warren Moon 3
5. Fran Tarkenton 3
6. Vinny Testaverde 3
7. Peyton Manning 3
8. Drew Bledsoe 3
9. Dan Fouts 4
10. Joe Montana 4
11. Johnny Unitas 3
12. Dave Krieg 3
13. Boomer Esiason 3
14. Kerry Collins 2
15. Jim Kelly 3
16. Jim Everett 3
17. Jim Hart 3
18. Steve DeBerg 3
19. John Hadl 3
20. Phil Simms 3
21. Steve Young 3
22. Troy Aikman 3+1= 4 (gotta get my homer pick in )
23. Ken Anderson 3
24. Sonny Jurgensen 3
25. Mark Brunell 2
26. John Brodie 3
27. Steve McNair 3
28. Norm Snead 3
29. Randall Cunningham 3
30. Joe Ferguson 3
31. Roman Gabriel 3
32. Donovan McNabb 3
33. Jake Plummer 3
34. Brad Johnson 3
35. Rich Gannon 3
36. Len Dawson 3
37. Kurt Warner 3
39. Trent Green 3
40. Y.A. Tittle 3
41. Ron Jaworski 3
42. Terry Bradshaw 3
43. Ken Stabler 4
44. Craig Morton 2
45. Joe Namath 3
48. George Blanda 5
49. Steve Grogan 3-1=2
50. Bobby Layne 3
51. Tom Brady 3

[twinzs]

1. Brett Favre 4 - 1 = 3
2. Dan Marino 7 + 1 = 8
3. John Elway 5
4. Warren Moon 3
5. Fran Tarkenton 3
6. Vinny Testaverde 3
7. Peyton Manning 3
8. Drew Bledsoe 3
9. Dan Fouts 4
10. Joe Montana 4
11. Johnny Unitas 3
12. Dave Krieg 3
13. Boomer Esiason 3
14. Kerry Collins 2
15. Jim Kelly 3
16. Jim Everett 3
17. Jim Hart 3
18. Steve DeBerg 3
19. John Hadl 3
20. Phil Simms 3
21. Steve Young 3
22. Troy Aikman 4
23. Ken Anderson 3
24. Sonny Jurgensen 3
25. Mark Brunell 2
26. John Brodie 3
27. Steve McNair 3
28. Norm Snead 3
29. Randall Cunningham 3
30. Joe Ferguson 3
31. Roman Gabriel 3
32. Donovan McNabb 3
33. Jake Plummer 3
34. Brad Johnson 3
35. Rich Gannon 3
36. Len Dawson 3
37. Kurt Warner 3
39. Trent Green 3
40. Y.A. Tittle 3
41. Ron Jaworski 3
42. Terry Bradshaw 3
43. Ken Stabler 4
44. Craig Morton 2
45. Joe Namath 3
48. George Blanda 5
49. Steve Grogan 3-1=2
50. Bobby Layne 3
51. Tom Brady 3

[VaultMan]

1. Brett Favre 3
2. Dan Marino 8
3. John Elway 5
4. Warren Moon 3 + 1 = 4
5. Fran Tarkenton 3
6. Vinny Testaverde 3
7. Peyton Manning 3
8. Drew Bledsoe 3
9. Dan Fouts 4
10. Joe Montana 4
11. Johnny Unitas 3
12. Dave Krieg 3
13. Boomer Esiason 3
14. Kerry Collins 2
15. Jim Kelly 3
16. Jim Everett 3
17. Jim Hart 3
18. Steve DeBerg 3
19. John Hadl 3
20. Phil Simms 3
21. Steve Young 3
22. Troy Aikman 4
23. Ken Anderson 3
24. Sonny Jurgensen 3
25. Mark Brunell 2
26. John Brodie 3
27. Steve McNair 3
28. Norm Snead 3
29. Randall Cunningham 3
30. Joe Ferguson 3
31. Roman Gabriel 3
32. Donovan McNabb 3
33. Jake Plummer 3
34. Brad Johnson 3
35. Rich Gannon 3
36. Len Dawson 3
37. Kurt Warner 3
39. Trent Green 3
40. Y.A. Tittle 3
41. Ron Jaworski 3
42. Terry Bradshaw 3
43. Ken Stabler 4
44. Craig Morton 2 - 1 = 1
45. Joe Namath 3
48. George Blanda 5
49. Steve Grogan 2
50. Bobby Layne 3
51. Tom Brady 3

[Teague]

1. Brett Favre 3
2. Dan Marino 8
3. John Elway 5
4. Warren Moon 4
5. Fran Tarkenton 3
6. Vinny Testaverde 3
7. Peyton Manning 3
8. Drew Bledsoe 3
9. Dan Fouts 4
10. Joe Montana 4
11. Johnny Unitas 3
12. Dave Krieg 3
13. Boomer Esiason 3-1=2
14. Kerry Collins 2
15. Jim Kelly 3
16. Jim Everett 3
17. Jim Hart 3
18. Steve DeBerg 3
19. John Hadl 3
20. Phil Simms 3
21. Steve Young 3
22. Troy Aikman 4
23. Ken Anderson 3
24. Sonny Jurgensen 3
25. Mark Brunell 2
26. John Brodie 3
27. Steve McNair 3
28. Norm Snead 3
29. Randall Cunningham 3
30. Joe Ferguson 3
31. Roman Gabriel 3
32. Donovan McNabb 3
33. Jake Plummer 3
34. Brad Johnson 3
35. Rich Gannon 3
36. Len Dawson 3
37. Kurt Warner 3
39. Trent Green 3
40. Y.A. Tittle 3
41. Ron Jaworski 3
42. Terry Bradshaw 3
43. Ken Stabler 4
44. Craig Morton 1+1=2 C'mon--starting QB in two Superbowls for two different teams?
45. Joe Namath 3
48. George Blanda 5
49. Steve Grogan 2
50. Bobby Layne 3
51. Tom Brady 3

[Raven1014]

1. Brett Favre 3 - 1 = 2
2. Dan Marino 8 + 1 = 9
3. John Elway 5
4. Warren Moon 4
5. Fran Tarkenton 3
6. Vinny Testaverde 3
7. Peyton Manning 3
8. Drew Bledsoe 3
9. Dan Fouts 4
10. Joe Montana 4
11. Johnny Unitas 3
12. Dave Krieg 3
13. Boomer Esiason 2
14. Kerry Collins 2
15. Jim Kelly 3
16. Jim Everett 3
17. Jim Hart 3
18. Steve DeBerg 3
19. John Hadl 3
20. Phil Simms 3
21. Steve Young 3
22. Troy Aikman 4
23. Ken Anderson 3
24. Sonny Jurgensen 3
25. Mark Brunell 2
26. John Brodie 3
27. Steve McNair 3
28. Norm Snead 3
29. Randall Cunningham 3
30. Joe Ferguson 3
31. Roman Gabriel 3
32. Donovan McNabb 3
33. Jake Plummer 3
34. Brad Johnson 3
35. Rich Gannon 3
36. Len Dawson 3
37. Kurt Warner 3
39. Trent Green 3
40. Y.A. Tittle 3
41. Ron Jaworski 3
42. Terry Bradshaw 3
43. Ken Stabler 4
44. Craig Morton 2
45. Joe Namath 3
48. George Blanda 5
49. Steve Grogan 2
50. Bobby Layne 3
51. Tom Brady 3

[hawkeyethearcher]

1. Brett Favre 2
2. Dan Marino 9
3. John Elway 5
4. Warren Moon 4
5. Fran Tarkenton 3
6. Vinny Testaverde 3
7. Peyton Manning 3
8. Drew Bledsoe 3
9. Dan Fouts 4
10. Joe Montana 4
11. Johnny Unitas 3
12. Dave Krieg 3
13. Boomer Esiason 2
14. Kerry Collins 2
15. Jim Kelly 3
16. Jim Everett 3
17. Jim Hart 3
18. Steve DeBerg 3
19. John Hadl 3
20. Phil Simms 3
21. Steve Young 3
22. Troy Aikman 4
23. Ken Anderson 3
24. Sonny Jurgensen 3
25. Mark Brunell 2
26. John Brodie 3
27. Steve McNair 3
28. Norm Snead 3
29. Randall Cunningham 3
30. Joe Ferguson 3
31. Roman Gabriel 3
32. Donovan McNabb 3
33. Jake Plummer 3 - 1 = 2
34. Brad Johnson 3
35. Rich Gannon 3
36. Len Dawson 3
37. Kurt Warner 3
39. Trent Green 3
40. Y.A. Tittle 3
41. Ron Jaworski 3
42. Terry Bradshaw 3
43. Ken Stabler 4 + 1 = 5
44. Craig Morton 2
45. Joe Namath 3
48. George Blanda 5
49. Steve Grogan 2
50. Bobby Layne 3
51. Tom Brady 3

[VaultMan]

I cant believe Brett Favre has taken a strike already!

[TNovak]

Originally Posted by VaultMan

I cant believe Brett Favre has taken a strike already!

I try to play these games straight up, by that I mean I vote for who I think deserves a plus vote the most or at least needs a plus vote to stay in and I feel deserves it and then negative the one that I think should be the next to go.

As a strategy, however, if you want to get rid of someone who will be tough for your guy to beat, killing them off early before they get many votes makes more sense. I suspect that is what happened here. I can't believe someone thinks Favre is the worst QB on this list at the moment.

[hawkeyethearcher]

Originally Posted by VaultMan

I cant believe Brett Favre has taken a strike already!

i can. i wouldnt give him a strike before a lot of others on the list but he did make you hold your breath when he threw the ball. he wouldnt be in my list of top ten quarterbacks of all time.

i wonder how much further blandas name would be on this list if he had 16 games to play a season. also when did they start keeping these stats and does it include the old afl stats i wonder

[biglebowski9999]

1. Brett Favre 2
2. Dan Marino 9
3. John Elway 5+1=6
4. Warren Moon 4
5. Fran Tarkenton 3
6. Vinny Testaverde 3
7. Peyton Manning 3
8. Drew Bledsoe 3
9. Dan Fouts 4
10. Joe Montana 4
11. Johnny Unitas 3
12. Dave Krieg 3
13. Boomer Esiason 2
14. Kerry Collins 2
15. Jim Kelly 3
16. Jim Everett 3
17. Jim Hart 3
18. Steve DeBerg 3
19. John Hadl 3
20. Phil Simms 3
21. Steve Young 3
22. Troy Aikman 4
23. Ken Anderson 3
24. Sonny Jurgensen 3
25. Mark Brunell 2
26. John Brodie 3
27. Steve McNair 3
28. Norm Snead 3
29. Randall Cunningham 3
30. Joe Ferguson 3
31. Roman Gabriel 3
32. Donovan McNabb 3
33. Jake Plummer 2
34. Brad Johnson 3
35. Rich Gannon 3
36. Len Dawson 3
37. Kurt Warner 3
39. Trent Green 3
40. Y.A. Tittle 3
41. Ron Jaworski 3
42. Terry Bradshaw 3
43. Ken Stabler 5
44. Craig Morton 2
45. Joe Namath 3
48. George Blanda 5
49. Steve Grogan 2-1=1
50. Bobby Layne 3
51. Tom Brady 3