Does anyone rank Batman v Superman in their Top Ten Comic Book Movie List...?

VaultMan · 03-26-2016, 07:40 PM

Of all time...?

For me, no. Top twenty. Maybe. I would have to make the list.

VaultMan · 03-26-2016, 07:45 PM

Just worked through a top ten. Definitely didn't make the cut, but possibly could make top twenty - mostly because the number of movies started to thin out LOL

risingstar · 03-26-2016, 08:09 PM

Hmmm....

Let's see what I would rate as better or more entertaining.
Not in any order:

Dark Knight (Heath Ledger)
Spiderman 2 (Doc Ock)
X-Men - First Class
GOTG
Ant-Man
Cap 2
Iron Man
X-Men 2 (Nightcrawler)
Spiderman 1
Superman 1 (Reeve)
Superman 2 (Reeve)
Batman 1 (Burton)
Batman 2 (Burton)
Batman Begins
Avengers 1
X-Men DOFP
Unbreakable
The Crow
Cap 1

That's 19 right there so no, Bats vs Supes would not make my top 10 but it would just make my top 20 at #20.

risingstar · 03-26-2016, 08:13 PM

It might be easier to say what I liked less:

Both Hulk films
Both Wolverine films
The 2 post Burton Batman films
Avengers 2
Iron Man 2 and 3
Daredevil
Elektra
Catwoman
Crow 2 and beyond
Dark Knight rises (Bane)
Spiderman 3
Kick Ass 1 and 2
Superman 3 and 4 (Reeve)
X-Men 3 (Dark Phoenix)
Man of Steel (revamp with Cavill)
Superman returns
Spider man 1 and 2 (revamps with Stone/Garfield)
Thor 1 and 2
Blade

This would likely make my bottom 25. It doesn't necessarily mean I disliked these flicks. I liked quite a few of them, actually.
Bats vs Supes would be listed right in between my top and bottom 20.

moon_knight1971 · 03-26-2016, 08:32 PM

Simply put NO. This was a one and done for me and it seems a lot of people are equally unsatisfied. The sad part is that curiosity and love for these 3 great characters will ensure that the movie will make money which will in turn likely be misinterpreted as deeming this movie a success.

VaultMan · 03-26-2016, 08:49 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by moon_knight1971

Simply put NO. This was a one and done for me and it seems a lot of people are equally unsatisfied. The sad part is that curiosity and love for these 3 great characters will ensure that the movie will make money which will in turn likely be misinterpreted as deeming this movie a success.

Agreed. And even though the reviews have been negative, many of our fandom colleagues have been far kinder. Just another "reason" for Hollywood to call this a winner

built2shred · 03-26-2016, 09:00 PM

I would rate it better then all the Christopher Reeve movies... Even though Superman 1 & 2 were cool at the time as a 8 year watching them. But once you grow up and watch them, they were extremely cheesy, especially with the rewind time by making the earth spin in a different direction or weird powers like at the end of Superman 2 (IE: Chest Symbol and duplicates, etc..)

I would rate BvS better then Thor 2 and Iron Man 3, so it's defiantly not the worst Hero movie out there..

I think most people will enjoy the movie for what it is, entertainment....

gomur · 03-26-2016, 09:13 PM

It's a trendy thing to hate on Batman v Superman. There was a lot of vitriol circulating before I even saw it on opening night. How can that much resentment build up before the movie is even out?

I went in with an open mind and actually enjoyed it. And I'm looking forward to a second viewing.

Top 10 for me? No. But neither is Avengers 2 or The Shadow, and other superhero flicks I've enjoyed.

JP Sarri · 03-26-2016, 10:20 PM

Nah. The plot was nonsensical to say the least.

TheYoungWolf · 03-26-2016, 11:06 PM

Sure do.

Though it's not on the same level as, CA: Winter Soldier, for example, I enjoyed this far more than any other live-action DC film to date and quite a bit more than many Marvel titles as well.