I guess I'm looking at this poll differently. I'm looking at it as in the ideal world - who do I think looks the part of Superman. The story is obviously going to be dictated by things other than looks.
So for Whose My Superman "Superficial" Style: Christopher Reeve, but damn if Henry Cavill isn't just a fiiiinnneeee lookin man
He just gets beat because he's too attractive to be a mild-mannered Clark
Kent.
Oh and ITA with those who like Animated Supes the best