Need some opinions

[joefixit2]

Sell the Black Cat. Catwoman is personalized so I would keep that one.

[marvelboi77]

Originally Posted by Tetragrammaton

I wonder if selling both cats together would fetch a higher price.

If I had to choose one of the two to sell, it would be the Black Cat, but I think you would get more $ for Catwoman.

Put them both up on the same auction. But say the high bidder gets to choose which one. That way you may have more bidders.

[Scottsdale Saint]

I'd keep Catwoman, Black Cat pose looks too much like a Greg Land porno shot.

[galactus]

The Black Cat, if I remember correctly, is the cover piece from one of his sketchbooks, isn't it? At a minimum, I think it was at least in one of the sketchbooks released by Dodson.

[Blastomussa]

Thanks for all the comments, guys. I still don't know which one I'm going to go with - I think it will be a toss up in my mind until Sunday night. Putting them both up in the same auction and allowing the winner to decide is an intriguing thought, but I think it might be too confusing - especially for the foreign bidders who usually win the majority of my art auctions.

I don't have any expectations for what price they may realize, especially since I don't have a lot of money invested in either piece. I paid $50 for the Black Cat and $80 for Catwoman. I'd like to keep them both, but something's gotta give. Having the killer page of Ivy does help.

[capsteverogers]

Bill,
If you list the Black Cat piece on eBay I will be bidding

[whd]

Personally, I would hold onto the Catwoman piece and sell the Black Cat.

[Solstrom]

Originally Posted by Underdog07

I think it depends on how much $$$ you want to raise. The page will bring the most, followed by Catwoman and lastly the Black Cat. If you sell Black Cat and do not raise enough funds, you'll be bummed and may have to consider selling one of the others anyway and then you would be out 2 of the 3.

Bill, I gotta agree with Underdog's perspective on this one. As a collector who'd bid on it, I'd tell you to sell the Catwoman because I think it's a prettier illustration. And you'd certainly raise more more with that one. But if it were my collection, I'd put up the Black Cat, as its not personalized and doesn't have the beautiful shading Catwoman does.

And I've already professed my envy and love for the Ivy piece from Harley #1 in the "I love what this person has" thread. While selling either the Catwoman or Black Cat might be difficult, you'll still retain the jewel of your Dodson collection.

Jeremy

[Blastomussa]

Thanks for all of the great opinions, guys! I've been leaning towards the Black Cat and in the end, its the one I'm going to go with. Anyone who's interested will see it tonight on eBay, along with a handful of other pieces.

[Wookiee]

What's your ebay ID so we can find you?