Which Character Personifies Heroism More: Superman or Captain America?

[Argonus]

Originally Posted by MrYac

i didn't mean you, but there is a lot of anti-DCism in this forum, so pretty much any time it's a DC Vs Marvel thing DC gets thrashed

Ah.. fair enough.

Thankfully, though they lack the numbers, the DC "zombies" are usually quite the outspoken bunch.

[MrYac]

i try to keep my zombification to a minimium, somebody has to try and keep the biasis crowd in check

[Argonus]

Originally Posted by MrYac

i try to keep my zombification to a minimium, somebody has to try and keep the biasis crowd in check

Well played.

[VaultMan]

Originally Posted by MrYac

the whole "but he can die" argument is just as much crap as is the "but he has no powers" if these were real guys then sure it might matter, but since Cap is just as unlikely to be killed as Supes is on any given day makes the point invalid, both men will selflessly live to protect somebody and are just as willing to give up their lives to do the same, considering how much DC (and lets be honest superman) hate there is around here i knew this thread would be a landslide, but that doesn't mean i can't try to reason with you guys

Oh please, are we playing the "these are fictional characters, so neither will ever be killed" card? Good lord.

Bottom line - a man that can be shot and charging the beach at Normandy is more courageous than someone who has bullets fly off their chest. It makes no sense what youre saying. Stop being a DC-nationist lol

[VaultMan]

Originally Posted by MrYac

i try to keep my zombification to a minimium, somebody has to try and keep the biasis crowd in check

So your role here is to keep the Marvel zombies at bay, not to actually vote with your comic mind?! I strike you! LOL

[VaultMan]

Originally Posted by Argonus

Well played.

Dont lie to him lol

[Argonus]

Originally Posted by VaultMan

Dont lie to him lol

[MrYac]

Originally Posted by VaultMan

Oh please, are we playing the "these are fictional characters, so neither will ever be killed" card? Good lord.

Bottom line - a man that can be shot and charging the beach at Normandy is more courageous than someone who has bullets fly off their chest. It makes no sense what youre saying. Stop being a DC-nationist lol

of course it makes sense, Cap is just as unlikely to die then Superman, Wonder Woman or Galactus is on any adventure, the feigned "danger" aspect should not factor into what any of them actually does on a daily basis, they are both selfless heroes that put others ahead of themselves, just because one is stronger then the other isn't a factor in my mind

Originally Posted by VaultMan

So your role here is to keep the Marvel zombies at bay, not to actually vote with your comic mind?! I strike you! LOL

how am i not thinking with my comic mind, Superman has given up everything he cares about to keep the earth safe, just because he is stronger then Cap doesn't make that any less of a sacrifice

[VaultMan]

Just to use the WWII context just one more time...

So a guy running alongside a tank with a handgun is taking the same risk as the guy driving the tank? No way.

EXCEPT that in this scenario, something could actually stop the tank -nothing is stopping supes lol

[MrYac]

but why does risk alone define heroism to you?