Martin Scorsese and Francis Ford Coppola trash MCU

[galactus]

Originally Posted by The Dark Knight

Not according to someone, this is how art works. By information i mean objective observations about life, about politics about human beings or some political system like for example socialism or capitalism or something.

Can you please cite your sources for your statements?

[The Dark Knight]

Originally Posted by galactus

Can you please cite your sources for your statements?

My sources are my 4 years of art history and design lessons.

[off]

Originally Posted by The Dark Knight

I won't get into politics, i just give an example... To create art, you must be genious. Art requires extra ordinary intelegence. Only a this kind of guy can make objective observations about politics rather then have an agenda. He's worth listining.

Is English your first language? Serious question.

[The Dark Knight]

Originally Posted by off

Is English your first language? Serious question.

No, sorry for my silly mistakes in english.

[galactus]

Originally Posted by The Dark Knight

My sources are my 4 years of art history and design lessons.

Well, that's where you listened to teachers and perhaps discussed these theories with your fellow students. But when presenting "facts", there should be a scientific or quantitative analysis that fully supports the facts.

So, teachers and fellow students aren't actually sources of fact, they're sources of opinions. Where are the sources that THEY gleaned these "facts" from?

[off]

Originally Posted by The Dark Knight

No, sorry for my silly mistakes in english.

No prob. Not silly, was just hard to follow at times.

[The Dark Knight]

Originally Posted by galactus

Well, that's where you listened to teachers and perhaps discussed these theories with your fellow students. But when presenting "facts", there should be a scientific or quantitative analysis that fully supports the facts.

So, teachers and fellow students aren't actually sources of fact, they're sources of opinions. Where are the sources that THEY gleaned these "facts" from?

Oh, they were fellow architects, and architects know art. You don't believe me, so be it. Get an art history book and study. I had my art history papers but who knows where they are, it has been 10 years since i graduated.

[galactus]

Originally Posted by The Dark Knight

Oh, they were fellow architects, and architects know art. You don't believe me, so be it. Get an art history book and study. I had my art history paper but who know where they are, it has been 10 years since i graduated.

Great, which art history book? I mean, every math book says 2+2 is 4. Every science book will tell you that water is made up of two molecules of Hydrogen and one of Oxygen. So every art history book will give me your four key "facts of art", yes?

1) If it's not new, it's not art?
2) If it doesn't convey information (whatever this is supposed to mean), it's not art?
3) ALL "super hero" comics are violent and about raising soldiers?
4) If it's not realistic (represents something in real life), it's not art?

Please, provide me a book to read which has the chapters that cover each of these topics.

Thanks!!

[The Dark Knight]

Originally Posted by galactus

Great, which art history book? I mean, every math book says 2+2 is 4. Every science book will tell you that water is made up of two molecules of Hydrogen and one of Oxygen. So every art history book will give me your four key "facts of art", yes?

1) If it's not new, it's not art?
2) If it doesn't convey information (whatever this is supposed to mean), it's not art?
3) ALL "super hero" comics are violent and about raising soldiers?
4) If it's not realistic (represents something in real life), it's not art?

Please, provide me a book to read which has the chapters that cover each of these topics.

Thanks!!

Art history book don't give you that information, it only teachs you the relics of past. To learn that you need design lessons from an wise and old architect teacher of mine... those were fun days... lol Read world classics novels.

[galactus]

Originally Posted by The Dark Knight

Art history book don't give you that information, it only teachs you the relics of past. To learn that you need design lessons from an wise and old architect teacher of mine... those were fun days... lol Read world classics novels.

Great. So where is the design book that provides this information? I mean, c'mon, these are "facts" you're giving us. Surely there's some written record of these "facts"?