Does anyone rank Batman v Superman in their Top Ten Comic Book Movie List...?

[marvelboi77]

I liked it more then Age of Ultron.

[Ryu]

Nope, it has Mark Webb's The Amazing Spiderman problems. It's more worried about setting up JL than telling a self contain coherent story and character development. They really painted themselves in a weird corner going forward with the decisions that they made for the characters. I think Snyder is somewhat a Micheal Bay light, he's more concerned about style and less about substance. He doesn't seem to understand what makes these characters tick. I did like 300, and oddly enough, I pictured the JL standing in front of a wall made of dead bodies from the movie for some reason to this tune. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Of6I4ENoOSE I'm the goddamn Batman arrrghhraww!

Anyway, in no particular order
1.Captain America WS
2.The Dark Knight
3.Scott Pilgrim
4.Spiderman 2
5.Edge of Tomorrow aka All you need is kill.
6.Kickass
7.X-Men DOFP
8.Blade
9.The Incredibles
10.Unbreakable

[JP Sarri]

Originally Posted by Ryu

Nope, it has Mark Webb's The Amazing Spiderman problems. It's more worried about setting up JL than telling a self contain coherent story and character development. They really painted themselves in a weird corner going forward with the decisions that they made for the characters. I think Snyder is somewhat a Micheal Bay light, he's more concerned about style and less about substance. He doesn't seem to understand what makes these characters tick. I did like 300, and oddly enough, I pictured the JL standing in front of a wall made of dead bodies from the movie for some reason to this tune. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Of6I4ENoOSE I'm the goddamn Batman arrrghhraww!

[VaultMan]

Originally Posted by marvelboi77

I liked it more then Age of Ultron.

I think I agree...

[ratchet]

Originally Posted by Ryu

Anyway, in no particular order
1.Captain America WS
2.The Dark Knight
3.Scott Pilgrim
4.Spiderman 2
5.Edge of Tomorrow aka All you need is kill.
6.Kickass
7.X-Men DOFP
8.Blade
9.The Incredibles
10.Unbreakable

Wow - what a great list, brother! I forget about Scott Pilgrim when talking about Comic Book movies - that's a fantastic one!

[nbr3bagshotrow]

I liked it more than GOTG. Wouldn't rate that one in my top 15.

[VaultMan]

Originally Posted by Matches Malone

That is what happens when you try and cram the set up Marvel played out over 5 films into 2

Yep

[VaultMan]

Its hard to keep these positions...these movies come in, and they go...hard to be consistent

Dark Knight
Spider-Man 2
Iron Man
Avengers
Cap Winter Soldier
Cap Civil War
GOTG
Blade
Donner's Superman
XMFC

[SONICobra]

I really liked it but I don't think it would make the top 10

[wktf]

Originally Posted by VaultMan

I think I agree...

Well, I disagree...but not by much. Age of Ultron had it's problems but BvS was a steaming disaster of a film that crumbled under its own weight of incoherency. I haven't done my own raking but no way this would make my top 10 and would struggle to make my top 20. To that point, I have absolutely no desire to see it a second time.