Quote:
Originally Posted by Matches Malone
Surprised you liked Punished: War Zone enough to want it on the list. While the scenes with Stevenson were awesome and ripped right out of the books the Jigsaw portions were absolutely unwatchable. There was such a disparity in style it seemed like two films.
I agree that the Any Lee Hulk and SR has no business on this list but the Watchmen was a pretty incredible, and unabashed, page to screen recreation of the source material; and then improved on the ending IMHO.
|
Yeah, I'm aware I'm probably in the minority with regards to the Watchmen. Other than Rorschach, I found myself not really caring about anyone else on screen. Oh well. Incidentally, I wasn't much of a fan of the mini series either. I tried liking it too. Then again, I loved Moore's Swamp Thing!
I slipped Punisher War Zone into the top 30 because it didn't really play it safe. It went places most Marvel movies would not. I was more forgiving regarding the Jigsaw segments which I agree weren't amazing.
