Quote:
Originally Posted by SunnyLee
The key differentiators here are - is it a critique based on your personal tastes (rendering style, animated or realistic, cartoony, etc) or based on artistic facts (basic anatomy, architecture, design, perspective, etc)? If it's the former, then it's criticism... if it's the latter, then it's a critique/feedback. I'm not saying you have to be an expert in art to offer a critique, but I would again refrain from offering any kind of input unless explicitly asked to do so because those lines are often blurred pretty quickly and can easily be misinterpreted. Then input becomes insult. Restraint is the best course of action here. Especially in the wide open domain that is the internet.
|
Quote:
Originally Posted by The Batfan
These are the Critiques I was talking about not if the character sucks because its not one you like or collect or its a style you don't like like a cartoony over a typical comic style.
|
Lee, don't forget the part of Sunny's statement after the part you bolded. I think everyone agrees that they would want HONEST feedback
but only if they request it. Most people are saying that they do NOT want a critique if they post the latest addition to their collection. Make sense?
