The Good, BAd, Ugly Reviews, All Star Batman, X-factor, New Avengers, Ultimate FF

[bat_collector]

Originally Posted by rychehitman

House of Quagmire!



BC...Ultimate FF is one of the best books out there today! Glad to see you putting a spotlight on it!

For pure fun and entertainment value, nothing is better than Ultimate FF. Cap's story may be more important, but this oen is just a delight to read. Glad you like it too man.

[Babytoxie]

So the general opinion so far is:

All-Star Superman - yea
All-Star Batman - nay

I'll admit, the Superman does look pretty good.

[hillis3]

Originally Posted by Babytoxie

So the general opinion so far is:

All-Star Superman - yea
All-Star Batman - nay

I'll admit, the Superman does look pretty good.

I'll agree with that.
I usually give any new book 3 issues but I cound not make it through the 2nd issue of All-Star Batman. I really did want to like this book.

[bat_collector]

Originally Posted by hillis3

I'll agree with that.
I usually give any new book 3 issues but I cound not make it through the 2nd issue of All-Star Batman. I really did want to like this book.

Hey, give all star batman #3 a try. At least black canary looks good. Has jim lee ever drawn women better than this arc?

toxie, definately give all star supes a try

[wktf]

Just read AS Batman #3. Some of the worst writing I've ever read. Hackneyed, cliche, and stilted. What the hell happened to Frank Miller? Does Black Canary look great? Sure. But so did Vicki Vale in the first issue and that was no reason to buy this trash. I'm with Hillis on this one. Three strikes you're out. I'm done with this book.

I disagree on New Avengers. While Cho's art was disappointing and his cover was dull and, sure, this story was more set up and not so much on action, I thought it was intriguing and next issue should be the pay off.

[bat_collector]

Originally Posted by wktf

Just read AS Batman #3. Some of the worst writing I've ever read. Hackneyed, cliche, and stilted. What the hell happened to Frank Miller? Does Black Canary look great? Sure. But so did Vicki Vale in the first issue and that was no reason to buy this trash. I'm with Hillis on this one. Three strikes you're out. I'm done with this book.

I disagree on New Avengers. While Cho's art was disappointing and his cover was dull and, sure, this story was more set up and not so much on action, I thought it was intriguing and next issue should be the pay off.

Hey, after all the agreeing we've done lately its back to form disagreeing.
First, I'm in no way giving a thumbs up to the story of AS Batman #3. AS much as I thought the black canary story was humorous, it isn't good. The only good things the art, and Jim Lee is in superb form. I'm still in it for af ew issues, but I no logner expect anythign from this title but eye candy.

BTW, did you see Miller's alternate cover. Gross.

As for new avengers. A big snooze in my book, buddy. Set-up is good and all, but alking over your corn flakes is just flat out BORING! And the bendizzz dialogue is just frustrating. "Umm, ughh, huh, what?" Yeah, whatever. HOpefully next issue has some payoff. Half of this series is good, some great, some woefully bad.

[Tony Coca]

Originally Posted by bat_collector

Hey, after all the agreeing we've done lately its back to form disagreeing.
First, I'm in no way giving a thumbs up to the story of AS Batman #3. AS much as I thought the black canary story was humorous, it isn't good. The only good things the art, and Jim Lee is in superb form. I'm still in it for af ew issues, but I no logner expect anythign from this title but eye candy.

BTW, did you see Miller's alternate cover. Gross.

As for new avengers. A big snooze in my book, buddy. Set-up is good and all, but alking over your corn flakes is just flat out BORING! And the bendizzz dialogue is just frustrating. "Umm, ughh, huh, what?" Yeah, whatever. HOpefully next issue has some payoff. Half of this series is good, some great, some woefully bad.

Hell if we want to talk about Sleeper books (zzzzzz) Zzzzentry is one.I love John Jr art but not even that is going to keep me on the book.

[bat_collector]

Originally Posted by Tony Coca

Hell if we want to talk about Sleeper books (zzzzzz) Zzzzentry is one.I love John Jr art but not even that is going to keep me on the book.

Is it that bad? I avoided that, avoided like the plague!

[ickwinzs]

hey has anyone did a review for "Revelations" ??

[marvelboi77]

Gonna have to disagree with you on the New Avengers #14 issue. I loved it.