Black Adam vs the XMen

[isculpt]

Also I think we need a ref!

[Ink]

x men

[RichBamf]

Originally Posted by Makkari1

Once again you don't get what I'm saying. I'm looking at what Rogue has done not how she should be. Rogue has defeated Thor depsite all his years of experience. She just touches you and bam she has you. Once again I'll say it, I can put a Xmen team together that would get murdered by Adam and I could put together a team that will murder him. Your augument is that no matter which X-team I put together Adam will murder them and that's just simply not true.

And once again you presume to tell me my intention in my posts, not once in this thread have I said that. You say you are looking at what Rogue has done rather than what she should do.

I quote, from the same page:

Originally Posted by Makkari1

If written correctly she should be the most dangerous because she can steal your power and not just one.

What else are you saying with this comment?

I say the same statement about a DC character and my comments are 'simply not true'. I'm so glad that Stan Lee and the Bullpen told you his motivations for every character Marvel would ever create, I wish I was that connected.

[RichBamf]

But whatever, I'm done now, I think I've made the point I was trying to make.

[Makkari1]

Originally Posted by isculpt

Hulk always wins!!! Unless he is the child like hulk but in reality, we cannot conclusively decide who would win because comic powers are as unpredictable as the joker!
Writers operate on peaks and troughs for each character.
The only real valid way is to take some sort of average of each individual's powers and fully assess the vs. argument. Are we talking about a full, at their prime and the world is at stake hero or a kill everything because i have lost everything villain? Do we base the power of the character on all writers interpretations? Or only valid and consistent versions? To argue about such high level'ed characters is really in itself a challenge as since these characters have faced such other characters of high level that we must compare those as well. We also must look at the original intention of the character. I'm not a dc expert or novice for that matter but I think DC operates on a much grand power level of characters. They have gods left and right whilst marvel as more cosmic alien type characters though smaller in number. Pluz we all have bias. I say the hulk when another says superman. Good day.

I have disagree with some of your premise Marvel has high end Gods out of this world. I think the reason that most people think the DC operates on a grander scale than Marvel is the facts that Marvel uses more logic to explain feats than DC.

[Makkari1]

Originally Posted by RichBamf

And once again you presume to tell me my intention in my posts, not once in this thread have I said that. You say you are looking at what Rogue has done rather than what she should do.

I quote, from the same page:



What else are you saying with this comment?

I say the same statement about a DC character and my comments are 'simply not true'. I'm so glad that Stan Lee and the Bullpen told you his motivations for every character Marvel would ever create, I wish I was that connected.

I said IMO she "should be" not that she is. Right now she is not he most dangerous mutant but she should still be able to contend with Adam. Now if Adam knows her power then he will find a way to win but in this scenario both are ignorant of the others powers.

[The Dark Knight]

Originally Posted by Makkari1

I have disagree with some of your premise Marvel has high end Gods out of this world. I think the reason that most people think the DC operates on a grander scale than Marvel is the facts that Marvel uses more logic to explain feats than DC.

oh i'm very fimiliar with that advance logic of marvel. It's so advance that they don't even have to explain it. wow...

[RichBamf]

Originally Posted by The Dark Knight

oh i'm very fimiliar with that advance logic of marvel. It's so advance that they don't even have to explain it. wow...

Yeah magic and retcons

[Justin]

Originally Posted by RichBamf

No way in hell could Rogue even touch BA, she just isnt fast enough.

Well then no one would touch BA unless they have Superspeed also, That would make comics pretty boring

[bat_collector]

oh my, there is so much I want to say to some of these posts, but I won't.