I received my 2nd 1/4 scale DCD piece the other day (Thanks Jon.
) and figured I'd share a few pics and some thoughts.
BATMAN
Side by side with Green Lantern
Let me start off by saying I am the proud owner of 29 Sideshow 1/4 scale Premium Format Figures. For me the 1/4 scale DCD Batman and GL (albeit mine is customized) are every bit as nice as my costumed superhero PFs from Sideshow. Which IMO is the only way you can compare these pieces. Film characters with realistic clothing will always look superior in a mixed media format when compared to comic characters in spandex.
Something that I think needs to be kept in perspective when comparing these pieces to their Marvel counterparts from Sideshow is both Batman and GL have a fairly basic costume design. Heroes like Captain America and Thor have a lot more going on with their outfits. Hence the opportunity to incorporate finer details. I honestly don't think these characters would look any different if Sideshow were producing them. I think the real question for collectors is do these costumes work in this format? Its something I found myself asking with Sideshow's Wolverine and Sabretooth PFs and I think it applies with these characters too. The format works for some of us and others not so much. I think its less a question of quality and more a question of personal taste because to me these 2 DCD pieces are totally on par quality wise with what I've seen from Sideshow.
In regards to Batman specifically I was on the fence for a long time with this piece. I'm now convinced my apprehension was due to collectors, for the most part, not properly photographing this piece or taking the time to manipulate and pose Batman's cape. Speaking of the cape the wires throughout allow you to completely tailor the look to your tastes which is VERY cool. The leather outside contrasts nicely with the softer shinier fabric used in the inside. Sculpt wise he looks great. Muscle definition looks realistic, his gauntlets, pose, cowl and expression are all spot-on IMO. If I were to take fault with anything it would be the color of the base (should have been grey,) the lack of detail and choice of color in the utility belt and the style of Batarang used. The latter is more of a personal taste thing for me though as I prefer the slimmer style Batarang. Detail wise the Batarang looks great though. Its shiny and heavy with a very solid feel to it.
Overall I'm very happy with this piece. It looks even better in person than I thought it would and I like it every bit as much as GL. After receiving this I'm even more excited for the upcoming Joker and Harley Quinn pieces.